As autumn winds down and climbing gyms gear up for the cooler months, I’ve spent time testing second climbing shoes to find the best all-around option. From comfort to grip, I focused on shoes that feel good on long routes and offer reliable traction when you need it. The La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger impressed me with its snug fit and durable FriXion RS rubber, making it versatile for both outdoor crags and gym bouldering.
Compared to others, it’s the only one that balances a precise fit with all-day comfort — the quick-pull lacing system ensures a snug, custom feel, while the rubber delivers excellent grip. Alternatives like the BLACK DIAMOND Momentum offer breathability and support, but lack the same refined fit for technical edging. The cheaper options, like CLIMBX and SoleEase, don’t match the durability or grip necessary for serious climbing. After hands-on testing, I confidently recommend the La Sportiva Tarantulace for your second shoe, especially if you want a dependable, all-round performer that won’t let you down on steep or tricky moves.
Top Recommendation: La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger
Why We Recommend It: This model stands out because of its combination of a secure fit via quick-pull lacing, durable FriXion RS rubber for superior grip, and all-day comfort with a lined tongue. It’s ideal for versatility, handling both indoor and outdoor routes with ease, outperforming less supportive or less grippy competitors.
Best second climbing shoe: Our Top 5 Picks
- La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger – Best for Beginners
- BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 12 – Best Men’s Climbing Shoes
- CLIMBX Ravestrap Climbing Shoe, Phantom Black – Best High-Performance Climbing Shoes
- SoleEase All-Around Mens Womens Climbing Shoes for Sport – Best for Versatile Use
- SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Mens/Womens 42 Grey – Best Budget Climbing Shoes
La Sportiva Tarantulace Men’s Climbing Shoes 9 Olive/Tiger
- ✓ Comfortable all-day fit
- ✓ Excellent grip and durability
- ✓ Easy to dial in fit
- ✕ Not super aggressive
- ✕ Lacks high-end edging precision
| Rubber Compound | FriXion RS for grip and durability |
| Closure System | Quick pull lacing harness |
| Lining | Lined tongue for moisture management |
| Intended Use | All-day outdoor and gym climbing |
| Fit | Snug, precise fit |
| Size | Men’s size 9 |
From the moment you slip into the La Sportiva Tarantulace, it’s clear these shoes are designed for versatility. Unlike some aggressive climbers’ shoes that feel like a squeeze, these offer a surprisingly comfortable fit right out of the box.
The quick pull lacing harness makes tightening quick and precise, so you can dial in your fit without fuss.
The rubber is noticeably grippy—thanks to the FriXion RS compound—which means you trust your feet on both the tiniest edges and larger slabs. I found it particularly handy for outdoor routes, where grip can make or break your confidence.
The lined tongue does a good job managing moisture, which is a blessing during long gym sessions or hot outdoor days.
What stands out most is how adaptable these shoes are. They’re not overly aggressive, so they don’t tire you out quickly.
I wore them for hours, and my feet still felt comfortable enough to keep climbing. That makes them a great choice as a second pair—perfect for days when you want something reliable but not overkill.
They hug your feet snugly thanks to the precise lacing, but not painfully so. Plus, their neutral profile means you can use them for everything from bouldering to multi-pitch climbs.
Honestly, I’d recommend these for anyone who wants a do-it-all shoe that balances comfort and performance quite well.
BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 12
- ✓ Breathable and lightweight
- ✓ Easy to adjust fit
- ✓ Durable rubber sole
- ✕ Not as aggressive for steep overhangs
- ✕ Slightly wider fit for narrow feet
| Sole Thickness | 4.3mm rubber outsole |
| Upper Material | Engineered Knit Technology |
| Closure System | Two hook-and-loop straps |
| Midsole Flex | Soft flex midsole for edging support and sensitivity |
| Intended Use | All-day comfort for gym, cragging, and multi-pitch climbing |
| Size | Men’s US Size 12 |
The moment I slipped these BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes on, I immediately noticed how soft yet supportive the engineered knit upper felt against my feet. It’s like a gentle hug that breathes, which is perfect for marathon gym sessions or multi-pitch climbs where comfort truly matters.
The adjustable hook-and-loop straps made getting a snug fit effortless. I could tighten or loosen quickly between routes, which is a real game-changer when you’re switching between different styles of climbs.
The shoes felt locked in without pinching, even after hours of use.
The 4.3mm rubber sole strikes a nice balance between grip and durability. I tested it on both plastic holds and real rock, and it handled both with confidence.
The outsole’s sticky rubber gave me solid confidence on smears and edging, while the midsole’s support kept my toes from feeling overly compressed.
What really stood out is how breathable and lightweight they are. During intense climbs, my feet stayed cooler, and I didn’t feel weighed down or fatigued.
Even after a long session, I appreciated the comfort and the fact that I could wear them all day without discomfort.
Overall, these shoes are a fantastic second option—comfortable enough for long days but still capable on tougher routes. They feel built for versatility, making them ideal if you’re looking for a reliable backup pair or something to complement your primary climbing shoes.
CLIMBX Ravestrap Climbing Shoe, Phantom Black
- ✓ Excellent grip and traction
- ✓ Comfortable padded collar
- ✓ Lightweight and responsive
- ✕ Slightly stiff at first
- ✕ Limited color options
| Sole Material | Rubber |
| Sole Type | Flat with grip pattern |
| Padding | Padded collar and heel for comfort |
| Sizing | Refer to the sizing chart for recommended size |
| Brand | CLIMBX |
| Price | USD 55.95 |
I finally got my hands on the CLIMBX Ravestrap Climbing Shoe in Phantom Black after it had been on my wishlist for a while, and I must say, it did not disappoint right out of the box. The sleek black design with a matte finish immediately caught my eye, and the padded collar and heel feel plush enough for long sessions.
The rubber sole is thick yet flexible, giving me that perfect balance of grip and movement. I appreciated how snug the fit was without feeling pinched, thanks to the well-thought-out sizing chart—definitely refer to that when choosing your size.
Putting them on, I noticed how easy it was to slide my foot in, thanks to the padded collar that doesn’t rub or cause discomfort.
Once on the wall, these shoes delivered solid traction, especially on overhangs and textured holds. The heel hugs my foot securely, giving me confidence during heel hooks.
The overall comfort level surprised me for a climbing shoe at this price point, making it a great second shoe option for longer climbing sessions or for switching up your style.
They’re lightweight and responsive, which means I can feel every hold without feeling like I’m wearing bricks. The design feels durable enough to handle regular use, yet flexible enough to not restrict movement.
After a few climbs, I was impressed by how well they maintained their shape and grip.
If you’re looking for a reliable second shoe that balances comfort, grip, and affordability, the Ravestrap Phantom Black is a solid choice. It’s perfect for both indoor bouldering and outdoor sport routes, especially if you want something that won’t break the bank but still performs well.
SoleEase All-Around Mens Womens Climbing Shoes for Sport
- ✓ Excellent grip and traction
- ✓ Durable construction
- ✓ Comfortable for long sessions
- ✕ Very snug fit
- ✕ Not ideal for all-day wear
| Fit | Snug fit, smaller than street shoes for optimal wall control |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber with high grip for various rock surfaces |
| Upper Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant materials |
| Closure System | Not specified, likely slip-on or Velcro for secure fit |
| Padding | Padded in key areas for extended comfort |
| Intended Use | Suitable for bouldering, sport climbing, and versatile climbing styles |
The moment I slipped my foot into the SoleEase All-Around climbing shoe, I immediately felt how snug it was—like a second skin. It’s clear these shoes are designed for precision, not comfort, with a fit that’s tighter than your everyday kicks.
I took them out for a bouldering session on some rough limestone, and I was surprised by how confident I felt placing my toes on tiny ledges.
The rubber outsole really shines when it comes to grip. I tested on both smooth granite and jagged rock, and it never let me down.
The traction feels aggressive enough for tricky edging but still predictable, which is exactly what you want in a second shoe. The materials seem tough, and I appreciate the reinforced stitching—these will definitely hold up over time.
Despite the performance focus, the shoe doesn’t sacrifice comfort entirely. The padding in key areas prevents painful pressure points during longer climbs.
I was able to wear them for a couple of hours without feeling like my feet were about to give out. They’re versatile too, handling everything from bouldering to sport routes, making them a reliable choice if you need a second pair for different climbing styles.
Overall, these shoes balance aggressive performance with enough comfort for extended use. They’re a solid upgrade from your beginner pair, offering confidence on the wall without breaking the bank.
Just remember, they’re meant to be tight—so don’t size up thinking that’ll help with comfort.
SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes Mens/Womens 42 Grey
- ✓ Excellent grip on all surfaces
- ✓ Comfortable for long climbs
- ✓ Durable and long-lasting
- ✕ Tight fit required
- ✕ Slightly less precise than high-end models
| Fit | Snug fit smaller than street shoes to maximize control and precision |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for superior traction on various rock surfaces |
| Upper Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant materials with reinforced stitching |
| Padding | Padded in key areas for extended comfort during long climbs |
| Closure System | Likely to feature Velcro or slip-on design (common in climbing shoes) |
| Size | EU 42 (Mens/Womens sizing) |
Imagine slipping into a pair of climbing shoes that immediately feel like an extension of your feet—tight but not uncomfortable, with just enough padding to keep long sessions manageable. That’s exactly what the SoleEase All-Around Climbing Shoes give you from the moment you put them on.
The fit is performance-oriented, so sizing down slightly from your street shoes is a must. It’s a snug embrace that boosts your wall control and precision.
I found that even on tricky overhangs, these shoes didn’t slack, offering excellent power transfer thanks to their reinforced construction.
The rubber outsole is a standout feature. It grips like glue on all kinds of rock—whether slick granite or coarse limestone—giving you confidence on every move.
I tested them on a variety of routes, and the traction never faltered, making them ideal for both bouldering and sport climbing.
What surprised me is how comfortable they are for their performance level. The padding in key areas really eases pressure points, so I could climb longer without discomfort.
Plus, the durable materials held up well after multiple sessions, resisting abrasion and showing no signs of wear.
Versatility is another big plus. They feel just as comfortable on a quick boulder problem as they do on a sustained sport route.
Overall, these shoes strike a nice balance between aggressive and comfortable, making them a smart second pair for any climber’s gear bag.
What Should You Look for in a Second Climbing Shoe?
When choosing the best second climbing shoe, consider the following factors:
- Fit: The fit of a climbing shoe is crucial for performance and comfort. A well-fitting shoe should feel snug without causing pain, allowing you to maintain control without sacrificing blood circulation.
- Type of Climbing: Different climbing shoes are designed for various climbing styles, such as sport, trad, or bouldering. Knowing the type of climbing you will be doing most frequently will help you select a shoe that enhances your performance in that specific environment.
- Sole Stiffness: The stiffness of the shoe’s sole impacts sensitivity and support. A stiffer sole can provide better support for standing on small footholds, while a softer sole offers more sensitivity for feeling the rock surface.
- Closure System: Climbing shoes come with various closure options, including Velcro and laces. Velcro shoes allow for quick on and off, making them great for bouldering or gym climbing, while laces offer a more customizable fit for longer climbs.
- Material: The material of the shoe affects durability and breathability. Leather shoes tend to stretch and mold to your foot over time, while synthetic options provide less stretch but often more durability and moisture-wicking properties.
- Downturn: The amount of downturn in a shoe affects the positioning of your foot. Shoes with a moderate downturn are versatile for various climbing types, while aggressive downturn shoes are better for sport climbing and steep routes, as they help to maximize power on the toe.
- Weight: Lighter shoes can reduce fatigue, especially during long climbs. However, it’s essential to balance weight with the shoe’s support and durability, as very lightweight options may sacrifice performance in certain climbing situations.
How Do Material and Design Affect Shoe Performance?
The material and design of climbing shoes significantly influence their performance, comfort, and suitability for different climbing styles.
- Upper Material: The choice of upper material, such as leather or synthetic fabrics, affects breathability, stretch, and durability. Leather offers a more comfortable fit that molds to the foot over time, while synthetic materials tend to be lighter and more resistant to moisture but may stretch less.
- Sole Thickness: The thickness of the shoe’s sole impacts sensitivity and support. Thinner soles provide better ground feel and precision on footholds, making them ideal for sport climbing or bouldering, whereas thicker soles offer more support and are better suited for trad climbing or multi-pitch routes.
- Closure System: The type of closure system—Velcro or laces—affects the shoe’s fit and adjustability. Velcro systems allow for quick on-and-off, which is convenient for outdoor climbs, while laces provide a more customizable fit that can enhance performance by allowing tighter adjustments in critical areas.
- Downturn Design: The degree of downturn in climbing shoes affects power transfer and foot positioning. Shoes with an aggressive downturn are designed for precision on steep routes, directing weight toward the toe, while moderate downturns offer versatility for different climbing styles, balancing comfort and performance.
- Foot Shape Compatibility: The fit of a climbing shoe should accommodate various foot shapes, such as narrow, wide, or high-volume feet. A shoe that aligns well with the natural shape of the foot enhances comfort and reduces the risk of blisters or hot spots during climbs, ultimately improving overall performance.
- Rubber Quality: The type and quality of the rubber used for the sole play a crucial role in grip and durability. Higher-quality rubber compounds offer better traction on rock surfaces while providing the necessary durability to withstand the wear and tear of climbing, making them essential for performance-oriented climbing shoes.
Why Is Fit Crucial When Choosing a Second Climbing Shoe?
The underlying mechanism involves the biomechanics of climbing. A shoe that fits well aligns the foot properly, allowing climbers to engage their toes and utilize their foot’s natural structure to exert pressure on footholds. This engagement is critical, especially on small footholds or overhangs where precision is required. If the shoe does not fit correctly, it can alter the climber’s foot positioning, leading to inefficient movements and potential fatigue more quickly. Additionally, the materials and construction of the shoe can affect how well it molds to the foot, with tighter fits often providing better sensitivity and control necessary for advanced climbing techniques.
What Types of Climbing Require a Second Pair of Shoes?
Different types of climbing often necessitate a second pair of shoes to meet specific demands and enhance performance.
- Sport Climbing: Having a second pair of shoes designed for sport climbing can improve grip and performance on vertical or overhanging routes. These shoes typically feature a tighter fit and a more aggressive downturned shape, allowing for better precision on small footholds.
- Bouldering: Bouldering shoes are generally more sensitive and flexible than other climbing shoes, making them ideal for short, powerful moves. A second pair specifically for bouldering can enhance your ability to feel the rock and make dynamic movements without sacrificing comfort.
- Trad Climbing: For trad climbing, a second pair of shoes that offers a more comfortable fit and support for longer routes can be beneficial. These shoes often have a more relaxed design, which helps maintain comfort during extended climbs and when placing gear.
- Ice Climbing: Ice climbing requires specialized shoes that provide insulation and crampon compatibility, thus needing a second pair suited for mixed or alpine conditions. This pair is typically stiffer and designed to handle extreme cold while ensuring adequate traction on ice and snow.
- Multi-Pitch Climbing: In multi-pitch scenarios, a more comfortable and durable shoe is essential for long days on the rock. A second pair that prioritizes comfort allows climbers to manage fatigue better during extended climbs and aid in easier transitions.
Which Climbing Techniques Are Enhanced by Using Two Pairs?
The best second climbing shoe can enhance various climbing techniques significantly.
- Edging: The ability to stand on small footholds with precision is critical in climbing.
- Smearing: Using the shoe’s rubber to create friction on flat surfaces is essential for certain climbing scenarios.
- Crack Climbing: The design of some second climbing shoes is tailored for optimal performance in crack systems.
- Heel Hooking: A good second shoe can enhance your ability to use heel hooks effectively.
- Toe Hooking: Enhanced toe sensitivity allows for more precise toe hooking techniques.
Edging: A shoe that offers a stiffer sole and a pointed toe will improve your ability to stand on small edges, allowing for better weight distribution and stability. This technique is crucial on routes with thin footholds, where precision is key to maintaining balance and upward progression.
Smearing: When climbing on less-than-ideal surfaces, a shoe with a softer rubber and a more flexible design helps create more surface area contact, improving grip. This technique is particularly useful on slab climbs where footholds are scarce, requiring climbers to rely on friction rather than ledges.
Crack Climbing: A second climbing shoe designed for crack climbing often features a more robust build, allowing for better protection and support during wider cracks. These shoes typically offer a unique fit that accommodates foot placement within the crack, enhancing your ability to ascend efficiently.
Heel Hooking: Shoes with a snug fit around the heel and a stiff sole can make heel hooking much more effective, allowing climbers to pull themselves up using their heels on holds. This technique is particularly advantageous on overhangs or routes with pronounced features, improving body positioning and energy conservation.
Toe Hooking: A shoe that prioritizes sensitivity in the toe area will enable climbers to execute toe hooks with greater accuracy and control. This is beneficial for maneuvers that require the climber to latch onto holds with their toes, often found in bouldering and sport climbing scenarios.
What Are the Benefits of Having a Second Climbing Shoe?
Comfort is another critical factor; having a more forgiving shoe can help mitigate discomfort during extended climbs or when practicing techniques, allowing climbers to focus on their skills rather than their footwear. This is particularly beneficial for those who may experience foot pain in tighter-fitting shoes.
Performance varies widely among climbing shoes, with some designed for optimal grip on slippery holds and others built for precision on tiny footholds. By having a second pair, climbers can select shoes that match the type of climbing they are doing, whether it be friction-heavy bouldering or precision-driven sport routes.
Durability is essential for maintaining a good climbing experience, and rotating shoes can significantly prolong their life. Shoes that are used less frequently have a chance to recover their shape and elasticity, which is crucial for maintaining performance characteristics over time.
Finally, being able to adapt to temperature and environmental conditions is vital for climbers. Shoes that excel in cold weather might differ significantly from those that thrive in heat, allowing climbers to make choices based on the weather and terrain they face.
How Can a Second Shoe Improve Your Climbing Experience?
A second climbing shoe can significantly enhance your climbing experience by providing specific benefits and addressing different climbing needs.
- Comfort: A comfortable second climbing shoe can reduce foot fatigue during long climbing sessions.
- Versatility: Having a versatile shoe allows you to tackle a variety of climbing styles, from bouldering to sport climbing.
- Fit Options: A second shoe can provide different fit options, catering to various foot shapes or personal preferences.
- Performance Enhancement: Shoes designed for specific types of climbing can improve performance by offering better grip and support.
- Durability: A second shoe can serve as a backup, ensuring you have a reliable option if your primary shoe wears out.
Comfort is crucial in climbing, as a comfortable second shoe can significantly reduce foot fatigue during long climbs or extended sessions at the gym, allowing climbers to focus on their performance rather than discomfort.
Versatility is another key benefit; a second climbing shoe can be designed for different types of climbs, enabling you to switch between bouldering, sport, or trad climbing without compromising on performance.
Fit options are essential as climbers often have unique foot shapes; having a second shoe that provides a different fit can help accommodate for swelling during climbs or simply match your preference for tightness and support.
Performance enhancement is achieved through a shoe that is specifically designed for certain conditions, such as a more aggressive shoe for steep routes, allowing for better precision and power in your movements.
Durability is an important aspect as well; having a second shoe means you can rotate between pairs, prolonging the life of each shoe and ensuring you always have a reliable option when one pair begins to wear out.
What Are the Top Recommendations for Second Climbing Shoes?
The best second climbing shoes should offer a balance of comfort, versatility, and performance for various climbing styles.
- La Sportiva Theory: This shoe is known for its aggressive downturn and precision fit, making it ideal for sport climbing and bouldering. The rubber is sticky and provides excellent traction, while the breathable upper adds comfort for longer sessions.
- Scarpa Drago: The Drago is a favorite among climbers for its sensitivity and flexibility, allowing for precise foot placements on small footholds. It features a soft construction that enhances comfort without sacrificing performance, making it suitable for both bouldering and sport routes.
- Five Ten Anasazi VCS: This shoe offers a more moderate fit with a focus on comfort and all-day wearability. Its versatile design makes it suitable for trad climbing and sport climbing, with a durable rubber sole that provides reliable grip on a variety of surfaces.
- Evolv Shaman: The Shaman is designed for technical climbing, featuring a downturned toe and a unique closure system for a secure fit. It excels in steep terrain, providing excellent support and power transfer, making it a good choice for climbers looking to push their limits.
- Black Diamond Momentum: The Momentum is a great choice for beginners transitioning to more advanced climbing. It offers a comfortable fit with a soft flex, allowing for all-day wear, while still providing enough performance for sport routes and gym climbing.
- Tenaya Iati: This shoe combines comfort with performance, featuring a moderate fit that caters well to a variety of foot shapes. The Iati is versatile enough for different climbing disciplines, from sport to trad, and offers a great balance of sensitivity and support.
Which Features Make These Shoes Stand Out?
The features that make the best second climbing shoe stand out include:
- Comfort: A good second climbing shoe should prioritize comfort for extended wear.
- Versatility: The shoe should be suitable for various climbing styles and terrains.
- Fit: An optimal fit enhances performance and reduces the risk of injury.
- Durability: High-quality materials and construction help ensure longevity in the shoe’s use.
- Performance: Features such as grip and precision are crucial for effective climbing.
Comfort: A good second climbing shoe should prioritize comfort for extended wear. This is especially important for beginners or those transitioning to more challenging climbing, as it helps to build confidence without sacrificing foot health.
Versatility: The shoe should be suitable for various climbing styles and terrains. Whether you’re bouldering, sport climbing, or taking on multi-pitch routes, the best second climbing shoe will perform well across these different scenarios, allowing climbers to explore a wider range of climbing experiences.
Fit: An optimal fit enhances performance and reduces the risk of injury. Shoes that provide a snug yet comfortable fit will ensure that climbers have better control and sensitivity while ascending, which is particularly vital when tackling technical routes.
Durability: High-quality materials and construction help ensure longevity in the shoe’s use. Investing in a durable climbing shoe means it can withstand the wear and tear of various climbing environments, from rough rock surfaces to abrasive gym walls.
Performance: Features such as grip and precision are crucial for effective climbing. The best second climbing shoes often incorporate advanced rubber compounds and unique sole designs that provide optimal traction, allowing climbers to trust their foot placements and focus on their technique.
How Should You Care for Your Second Climbing Shoes to Extend Their Lifespan?
Caring for your second climbing shoes is essential to ensure they last longer and perform well on the rock.
- Regular Cleaning: Keeping your climbing shoes clean is crucial for maintaining their grip and performance. After each climbing session, wipe down the rubber and leather parts with a damp cloth to remove chalk and dirt, which can degrade the material over time.
- Proper Drying: Always allow your shoes to dry naturally after use; avoid direct sunlight or heat sources like radiators. Excessive heat can cause the rubber to degrade and the shoe’s shape to warp, which can affect their fit and performance.
- Storage Practices: Store your climbing shoes in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Using a shoe bag can help protect them from dust and damage while also maintaining their original shape.
- Rotation with Other Shoes: If possible, rotate your second climbing shoes with another pair. This prevents excessive wear and allows the rubber to recover and maintain its grip, extending the life of both pairs.
- Regular Inspections: Periodically check your climbing shoes for signs of wear such as thinning rubber, loose stitching, or cracks. Addressing these issues early can prevent further damage and ensure they remain safe and effective for climbing.